Back to Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Wafer Cookies, 10.5 oz

Customer reviews

2.38 out of 5stars
(16 reviews)

Most helpful positive review

5.00 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchaser
02/01/2022
Loved the product but not the shipping packaging.
My husband loves the cookies to the point that the two packages I bought him were gone in two days!! My dislike is I have two Walmarts very close to where I live. I always have to order them from the next town over because I never find them in the stores anymore. They came in a bag and both pack were partially broken. It would have been nice if they had been in sheets of cookie like they should have been. Next time because there will be one, please put them in something more sturdy than a bag.
Skookie

Most helpful negative review

1.00 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchaser
11/18/2021
Love love these cookies but the delivery was horrible. They came opened n crushed.
valerie
14 reviews
Filter by:
Sort by:
  • 1.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    07/09/2023
    Disappointment
    I did not like the condition of the product. I did not open the package when it arrived. My sister informed me that they were all crumbled. I checked mine and they were the same way. Found out that all three of them were crumbled. I was disappointed once again.
    Linder
  • 4.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    06/16/2023
    Nice light snack
    I got the butter butter peanut butter wafer cookies and enjoyed them very much. They are a light snack and I loved the peanut butter filling. They remind me of peanut butter bars without the chocolate coating. It comes in a long bar that you have to break apart if you want smaller pieces. I wish they were already in manageable size pieces though. Can never get a clean break and can get a little messy with the crumbs. I felt it is a very light snack and not heavy on the stomach and guilt free.
    Ajann1983
  • 2.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    06/05/2023
    Not worth the calories in my opinion
    I have a major sweet tooth, yet because I try to stay fit and healthy, I indulge selectively. If I am going to sacrifice calories, it needs to be well worth it, and I'm sad to say that these aren't an option for me. When I reach for a dessert, I want something that is rich and decadent - these cookies don't fit either of those adjectives. These definitely taste better than vegetables, but the flavor is very mild. There is very little of that sweet peanut butter filling that makes Nutter Butters so great, yet there is a lot of wafer, which doesn't have much flavor at all. In addition to lacking flavor, these are messy, breaking and leaving crumbs everywhere (see photo). You definitely wouldn't want to eat these in the car!
    Kimandbill
  • 4.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    06/05/2023
    Giant!!
    I bought these just to see if we would like them. I am a big Nutter Butter Fan!! These are pretty good. The kids Really like them. It is a giant wafer!!
    Vanna16
  • 1.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    03/30/2023
    What am i supposed to do with these?
    This.. is just plain unacceptable.
    Tracy
  • 1.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    11/07/2022
    Disappointed
    They were open and I didn't notice until a few days later. Looks like it was cut with a box cutter. Very disappointed. They cost to much to be wasted like that??
    Dixon
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    02/01/2022
    Loved the product but not the shipping packaging.
    My husband loves the cookies to the point that the two packages I bought him were gone in two days!! My dislike is I have two Walmarts very close to where I live. I always have to order them from the next town over because I never find them in the stores anymore. They came in a bag and both pack were partially broken. It would have been nice if they had been in sheets of cookie like they should have been. Next time because there will be one, please put them in something more sturdy than a bag.
    Skookie
  • 1.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    01/21/2022
    Texture and Mess
    I was so disappointed. I love wafer cookies but not this. Not only the texture but so easy to crumble and make a mess. Tasted like styrofoam. I'll stick to the original Nutter Butters.
    laura
  • 1.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    01/14/2022
    Broken NutterButters
    These are really good. But when the order was delivered this is how they came. They should make sure when they ship an item this delicate to pack it with care. I believe the carriers had some part in this to not only Walmart.
    Pamela
  • 1.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    12/21/2021
    Horrible Customer Service, Shipping, Etc.
    I ordered these cookies to be delivered from the store on 12.18.2021. They arrived today, 12.21.2021 in deplorable condition. They were for my dad. I can't even get walmart to send me a package of cookies in decent conditon. Just awful customer service.
    Heather
  • 1.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    11/18/2021
    Love love these cookies but the delivery was horrible. They came opened n crushed.
    valerie
  • 1.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    07/25/2021
    Crushed and package open at a 3 inch cut
    I love these but these were crushed and the package has a 3 inch cut on the package. Unable to return or request replace/refund. Quality control failure at warehouse and ? packaging.
    drgldy
  • 4.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    06/14/2021
    Childhood favorite.
    I've always loved these wonderfully crisp, peanutty cookies, which I remember as Peanut Butter Patties, before the rebranding as Nutter Butter - there's something about the contrast in textures between the flaky wafer crust and the dense, starchy filling, that makes me smile every time. Too sweet, like most American cookies, but the wafers help to balance the sweetness of the filling.
    David
  • 1.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    12/03/2020
    CRUSHED COOKIES
    THE COOKIES CAME LATE AND WERE IN AN ENVELOPE COMPLETELY CRUSHED. SEE PHOTO.
    starbelle10
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    10/07/2016
    Love them
    They are really addictive! I love them because they are not overly sweet. However...lately I have had a couple issues. See attached photos. I will be contacting them to let them figure out the problems...so just don't eat without looking!
    Alened
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    06/30/2016
    He will never tire of this product.
    My husband has been buying this cookie for years. He takes a lunch to work and every day he takes these cookies. He eats them everyday for breakfast and snacks on them while watching tv. I've ask him many times over the years how he can eat this many and not get sick of even looking at them, but he says he will never get tired of them. So I've become accustomed to this obsession. He buys 3-4 pkgs a week, brings them home and puts them in sandwich bags for easy packing in his lunch. By the way, we've been married 57 years and not sure what year these cookies were introduced to the public but no doubt my husband has bought them from day one.
    Mimisan